Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

26/00188/OUT

Address Proposal Shrewsbury Town Council Decision

Land To The South East Of Battlefield Roundabout
Battlefield
Shrewsbury

Outline application for up to 570 new homes, land for a single form-of-entry primary school, a local centre with a total floorspace of no more than 500m2 (gross) town centre uses (Class E) and additional community uses, vehicular access from the A53 through the provision of a new roundabout, enhanced footpath links, and open space, with all matters reserved other than access

Objection
Application Date:
2026-02-04
Application Notes:
Shrewsbury Town Council objects to the outline planning application on the following grounds: The Council considers that the proposal represents an unsustainable and speculative form of development, which would cause significant and demonstrable harm to the spatial strategy for Shrewsbury, to the integrity of the Town Development Boundary, and to important environmental assets, including local open spaces and green infrastructure. The objection is grounded in the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF), the adopted Shropshire Core Strategy and SAMDev Plan, and established planning principles governing decision-making in the absence of an up-to-date Local Plan or a confirmed five-year housing land supply. 1. Principle of Development and the Plan-Led System The NPPF is clear that the planning system should be plan-led (paragraph 15), with development decisions made in accordance with adopted policies unless material considerations indicate otherwise. This application is a speculative proposal brought forward in the context of: • The absence of a confirmed five-year housing land supply; and • The lack of an adopted Local Plan. While the Council recognises that this situation may engage the “tilted balance” under paragraph 11(d) of the NPPF, this does not justify unplanned, ad-hoc development in locations which conflict with long-standing spatial, environmental, and sustainability objectives. Housing delivery alone does not equate to sustainable development. Granting permission would undermine confidence in the plan-making process and prejudice the proper planning of Shrewsbury and its surrounding settlements. 2. Development Outside the Defined Development Boundary The site lies outside the established Town Development Boundary and is not allocated for housing in the adopted plan. While it was previously allocated for employment use, the proposed housing represents a fundamental change of use. The proposal therefore conflicts with the settlement framework and represents an unplanned and unsustainable extension of the urban area. Approval would weaken the effectiveness of development boundaries as a policy tool and encourage further speculative proposals in similarly sensitive locations. 3. Unsustainable Location and Connectivity The NPPF seeks to promote sustainable patterns of development that reduce the need to travel and prioritise walking, cycling, and public transport. Members are concerned that the site does not provide safe, high-quality active travel routes to the town centre or key services. The development relies heavily on the private car, with limited evidence that walking, cycling, or public transport would be viable alternatives. The proposal also requires pedestrian crossings of the A49 and A53, raising concerns about safety, deliverability, and reliance on further infrastructure before the site can be safely accessed. 4. Flood Risk, Drainage, and SuDS The site is located in an area of flood risk, with potential for both surface water and fluvial flooding. Members are not satisfied that the application demonstrates: • The effectiveness of proposed drainage and SuDS measures; • The long-term management and maintenance of these systems; • That development would not increase flood risk downstream. The inclusion of SuDS features within public open space calculations also raises questions about the quality and usability of open space provision. 5. Infrastructure and Deliverability Concerns remain regarding the viability of the proposed school site, sewage infrastructure, and other essential services. The lack of clarity on these points creates uncertainty over the deliverability and sustainability of the development. 6. Landscape, Environmental and Green Infrastructure Impacts The development would result in a permanent change to the open landscape along the edge of Shrewsbury, eroding the separation between the town and country and surrounding settlements. The scale and location of the proposal could have harmful impacts on: • Local biodiversity and green infrastructure; • Visual amenity; • Recreational value of public open spaces particularly given that Swales have been added into accessible space allocations Insufficient information has been provided to demonstrate that these impacts can be satisfactorily mitigated at the outline stage. 7. Five-Year Housing Land Supply and Planning Balance While the local planning authority may currently lack a five-year housing land supply, this does not override policies relating to sustainable development, flood risk, or settlement boundaries. The adverse impacts of this proposal significantly and demonstrably outweigh any potential benefits, and the “tilted balance” in the NPPF does not provide a blanket justification for development in this unsustainable location. 8. Precedent and Cumulative Impact Approval would set a damaging precedent for further speculative development beyond the Town Development Boundary, undermining the spatial strategy for Shrewsbury and threatening incremental erosion of environmental and landscape assets. Conclusion For the reasons set out above, Shrewsbury Town Council strongly objects to the application. The proposal represents inappropriate and speculative development, contrary to national and local planning policy, undermining the plan-led system, and causing lasting harm to settlement strategy, sustainability objectives, landscape character, flood resilience, and green infrastructure.